Music News

The members of O-Town are making sure the public knows they have zero ties to Sean “Diddy” Combs amid the disgraced music mogul’s ongoing legal battles.

In an interview with The Hollywood Reporter published Tuesday (Jan. 14), bandmates Erik-Michael Estrada and Jacob Underwood alleged that their brand has suffered from false perceptions that Combs was involved with O-Town simply because the producer worked on separate seasons of Making the Band, the reality show on which the boy band got its start.

“We make a living touring and can’t afford to have [bookers] Googling us to find the latest Diddy clickbait,” Underwood told the publication.

“Of all the bands in Making the Band, we’re the only one not tied to him,” he added, noting that he’s never met Combs. “The more people confuse us with a Diddy band and post our pictures with his story, the more it goes against us.”

O-Town first formed on the inaugural season of Making the Band, going on to chart three songs on the Billboard Hot 100 and tour with Britney Spears at the turn of the millennium. Combs later became involved with other iterations of the reality TV show in the early 2000s, working with different groups such as Danity Kane, Da Band and Day26.

Decades later, Estrada, Underwood and bandmates Trevor Penick and Dan Miller are still going strong as a group (without original bandmate Ashley Parker Angel), while the Bad Boy Records founder is currently awaiting trial in prison on charges of sex abuse and racketeering. The accusations against him — which Combs has repeatedly denied — are sprawling, and O-Town says that having Making the Band in common with Combs has lost them lucrative deals, even after all these years.

For instance, O-Town’s agent, Matt Rafal, told THR that a large gaming company dropped the band from a year-end party billing due to confusion over the matter. “The offer was pulled due to the perception of the group being attached to Diddy,” Rafal said. “We made it clear O-Town’s Making the Band had no association with Diddy, but the company worried guests may be confused … Since the Diddy news, we’ve received questions and hesitancy from several talent buyers, especially for soft tickets like fairs and theme parks, as well as city-funded events.”

“I wish people looked at Making the Band and went, ‘Making the Band was O-Town and it was the pioneering brand for music reality television in the States,” Estrada added, calling the show “the blueprint” for programs like American Idol. “Unfortunately, the actions of one man have tainted the reality, which is four individuals who met on a reality show and are going strong 25 years later.”

Estrada also said that he did attend some of Combs’ parties in New York back in the day, and that “there was always a salacious energy” at the events. “He encouraged people to dip into their wild side, but I never witnessed anything firsthand,” the boy band star told the publication. “Gratefully, I can look my fiancé in the face and swear I never attended any after-hours version of a Diddy party.”

The “All or Nothing” singer also noted the irony of another disgraced music mogul’s associations with O-Town and Making the Band: Lou Pearlman, who spearheaded the series and managed O-Town, the Backstreet Boys and *NSYNC before he was convicted of running a half-billion-dollar Ponzi scheme in 2008. The businessman died in prison in 2016 while serving his 25-year sentence.

“We’ve already had a Lou and now we’re dealing with a Diddy … it’s the MO of our career,” Estrada said. “Despite the steep climbs, we’ve generated a successful national tour with Pop 2000, had families, done other projects and strengthened our bond with fans, so when noise like this creeps up, we’re in good standing with the people who matter most.”