Judge Rules In Favor Of Central Park 5 Against Donald Trump
Written by djfrosty on April 11, 2025
Almost a year after the Central Park Five sued Donald Trump for defamation for his slander of the five men, a judge has ruled that Donald Trump must face them in a court of law after unsuccessfully trying to get the lawsuit dismissed.
According to Raw Story, U.S. District Court Judge Wendy Beetlestone declined Trump’s legal team motion to have the case dismissed and stated that the case will proceed as Donald Trump lied during his debate with Kamala Harris and claimed that the men killed someone and pleaded guilty even though they were exonerated of the crime decades later. Trying to clean up the mess he made for himself during the debate, Trump’s lawyers claimed that his lies were protected under the First Amendment’s free speech grounds, but Judge Beetlestone was having none of it and informed them to get ready for what comes next.
Per Raw Story:
In a 20-page ruling on Thursday, Beetlestone said the court did not agree that Trump’s words were statements of opinion.
“Defendant’s assertions—that Plaintiffs pleaded guilty and that Plaintiffs killed someone—can be ‘objectively determined’ to be false, so Defendant’s statement must be construed as one of fact, not opinion,” the judge wrote.
“For the reasons set forth above, Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss shall be denied as to Plaintiffs’ defamation claim,” the ruling added.
The judge, however, dismissed additional claims of intentional infliction of emotional distress without prejudice, “thus allowing Plaintiffs leave to amend their Complaint with respect to that theory and that claim.”
While we hope that the 34-count felon is held accountable for one of his most infamous lies, the fact that he’s now the president with the power of an obviously loyal and bias Department Of Justice behind him, we’re not sure things will pan out as they should in a normal democracy.
What do y’all think about Trump’s latest legal setback? Will justice be served, or will it be rigged in his favor in some way, shape or form? Let us know in the comments section below.